Evaluation
Today, we again reviewed other people's presentations:
Nicholas Tse: Tui Hou by Jay Chou
* Good description of colours, and effect of this upon mood and message of the song.
* Good description of shot angles and distances and also how this helps to connect the viewer to the subject.
* Good description of visual transitions.
* Organization of content was bad, with multiple repetitions.
Luisa Lobo: If I Die Young by The Band Perry
* Good ideas, but oral presentation made it hard to hear what was being explained.
* Explanation of film concepts were a bit vague.
Cynthia So: Hello Again by JUJU
* Thorough explanation of the generic music video techniques, which is slightly unnecessary since we all know them.
* Good explanation of lighting to generate mood, and the use of camera shots to show facial expressions.
* Very deep description of techniques used to evoke emotional response.
* Good exploration of thematic functions of film concepts.
Georgie Reading: Rolling in the Deep by Adele
* Good acknowledgement of colour/lighting usage.
* Good examples of camera techniques.
* Good analyzation of effects and editing.
Nicholas Sung: Fix You by Coldplay
* Good observations relating to lighting and its effects.
* Accurate descriptions of camera distances, which sets the scene and later presents the sadness experienced by Martin (the singer).
* Very good descriptions of angles to emphasize the band's stature and also the dramatic scene of the huge audience.
* Very good, but brief, explanation of the rule of thirds.
* Editing descriptions were good.
* Presentation was over the time limit.
Evaluation
I stayed on task and created constructive criticism for presenters to improve in future. In my presentation, I can use some of what I saw today to improve my own analysis.
No comments:
Post a Comment